The "Larry Crowne" star -- who is one of Letterman's favorite celebrities -- gasped after she realized he had given the crowd the two-fingered salute.
It happened after Letterman explained to the Oscar winner how his biggest sadness in life was that his son did not have a brother or sister.
When the audience interrupted his conversation with a half-hearted, "aww," he let them have the "double bird" to show his disapproval.
Roberts, 43, has three kids with her husband Danny Moder: twins Hazel and Phinnaeus (both 6) and a son Henry, 4.
Letterman, 64, has a son Harry, 8, with his wife Regina Lasko.
Several years ago Letterman infamously did an inverted single flip-off to a viewer who sent him a letter claiming he watched the show upside down so that blood could rush to his head.
RELATED ON WONDERWALL:
RELATED FROM RADAR: