All kidding aside, Haynes isn't the first star to be confused with another famous face. In August 2011, The Hunger Games' Elizabeth Banks, 38, admitted she's constantly being mistaken for Chelsea Chelsea Bang Bang author Chelsea Handler, 37.
"I was sitting in Toronto and a guy walked up to me and said, 'Oh my god, my girlfriend loves you. She would die if I didn't get your autograph. This is so exciting!'" Banks said on Chelsea Lately. "He's like, 'I just love your books. I mean, My Horizontal Life. . .' I was like, 'Oh, he thinks he's meeting Chelsea Handler.' I couldn't ruin it for him!"