Likewise, Cibrian, now 37, tied the knot with Rimes in a beachside spring ceremony. "[Eddie and Brandi] also got married in the spring at the beach," the source says.
Late last year, Rimes also mimicked her man's first wife in yet another way -- for her breast enhancement surgery, the singer turned to the same plastic surgeon Glanville used -- and even got the same cup size!
The former and current Mrs. Cibrians also both drive white Range Rovers.
Other odd reminders of the newlyweds' rocky road to wedded bliss? Rimes and Cibrian cut the cake to the tunes of "I Got You Babe."
"Interesting," another source notes of the song selection. "Because that's the song they did a karaoke duet to at the wrap party of their movie [Northern Lights] in Canada when they were still married, in front of Brandi and Dean [Sheremet]!"
Cibrian even referenced his first marriage in his raucous wedding speech to guests. "Someone loves the f****** microphone and that's me! We've both had much larger weddings before, about 100-150 people both, but we just wanted our closest of friends and family here with us tonight," Cibrian told revelers on Friday. "The next one will be ever smaller though." he joked.
"I love you all," Rimes added: "Now let's have some cake, bitches!"
"Their speeches were so them," the second insider says.