Photo: TriStar Pictures; Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP
5 of 12
Played in the original by: Leilani Sarelle
Our pick: Kate Bosworth
Yeah, Kate Bosworth has more of a surfer-chick-next-door vibe to her, but she has the look to pull off Roxy, Catherine's hot lesbian lover. Jealous and a totally off her rocker, Roxy is all over the place, and Bosworth has the talent to go wild. Plus, let's be honest, how hot would the scenes with Johansson be?