- Photo: Invision/AP2 of 9
OG Islander: Bob Denver
Replacement: Christopher Mintz-Plasse, more popularly known as McLovin
"Island" Aptitude: Oh the lovably goofy McLovin. He might be a little on the young side, but his squeaky voice and natural nerditude would make him the ideal choice for the famous blundering sidekick.
From Crowd Ignite