Photo: Matt Sayles/WENN/FayesVision/MGM/Invision/AP
9 of 11
Role: Greg and Charlie Proffitt
Played in the original by: Jamie Wild and Jared Rushton
Our choice: Atticus Shaffer and Jared Gilmore
The Proffitt twins are trouble. One is unpredictable and wild, and the other is usually preoccupied with his latest invention -- or gluing people to things. That said, we thought that Atticus, who is best known for his role as the quirky kid from "The Middle" would be perfect as the loud and rowdy Greg. And Jared would be the ideal Charlie. "Once Upon a Time" fans may recognize this young actor -- he plays the Evil Queen's (and Emma's) precocious son on the show.