The case for naughty: It wasn't that long ago when this one was a walking fashion disaster. Where does she get off calling others out on their appearance? Especially Christina Aguilera for being overweight?
The case for nice: Fashion-wise, she's made considerable strides in the past few years. Today, she really understands the art of presenting oneself, and her judgments -- even when somewhat harsh -- are often spot-on. Besides, her tendency to offer her opinion is something she comes by genetically. Judging red carpet style on E!'s "Fashion Police" is actually a great fit for her, professionally speaking.