Just as David's broken heart was on the mend, he unknowingly fell into the rebound trap. The same year that Lara divorced her husband of two years, she became involved with David, only to grasp his bite-size heart and stomp on it. How? you ask.
On July 8, 1999, Jack Nicholson was involved in a car wreck in the Hollywood Hills, and Lara was the passenger. The actress bolted from the scene and later called David to say she'd been in an accident, but left the details vague. Possibly to spare David's feelings? Or to hide her cheating ways? Either way, after keeping things quiet in 1999, Lara and Jack took their relationship public -- and publicly broke the heart of one pint-sized funnyman.