On May 19, 1997, Sarah and Matthew were wed in front of 100 guests in a secret ceremony at the Angel Orensanz synagogue in New York. The bride wore a Morgane Le Fay ruffled black dress with a full skirt and a moss-green crinoline underneath. "I really regret that," Sarah later told Marie Claire. "I was too embarrassed to get married in white, and both Matthew and I were reluctant to have people pay so much attention to us. Which is ridiculous, because that's when you can relish the attention, when it's natural." While they went right back to work the day after the wedding -- Matthew on "Godzilla," Sarah on Broadway's "Once Upon a Mattress" -- the couple later honeymooned in Ireland.