Put a ring on it: She was "The Bachelorette" on Season 6. He was the contestant who stole her heart. Fittingly, they got engaged on the finale of the show in 2009.
Cancel the cake: Like so many couples on the ABC reality franchise, post-show reality proved to be too much for Fedotowsky and Martinez. An 18-month engagement delivered three canceled wedding dates and a final goodbye in November 2011 -- a sad sayonara that wasn't captured on film.