The rumor mill has long maintained that the Church of Scientology auditioned some of Hollywood's hottest young actresses for the role of a lifetime: Mrs. Tom Cruise. In addition to eventual bride Katie Holmes, Scarlett Johansson and even Lindsay Lohan were named among the women who supposedly auditioned for Tom and the church for the coveted role. In September 2012, Vanity Fair published an exposé on the audition process, claiming Iranian-British actress Nazanin Boniadi was chosen to date Tom from November 2004 until January 2005, before Katie Holmes eventually won the part. But reps for Tom and the Church of Scientology have both vehemently denied the allegations. So unless you're willing to undergo a major religious conversion, you may never know the truth!