Before all the lawsuits, arrests, probation and public humiliation, Lindsay Lohan was regarded as quite a catch in this town. She was a rising star with a couple of hit movies under her belt in "Freaky Friday" and "Mean Girls" when Wilmer dove in and swept her off her feet. Only problem? He was diving in the kiddie pool: Lindsay was underage! The duo managed to keep their relationship under wraps until LiLo turned 18 in July 2004, but Wilmer said it had nothing to do with dodging the police. "We try to keep it more under wraps because it is a lot more meaningful that way," he told People. "At this point we don't need all the free press." They would soon get plenty of complimentary print a few months later after they parted ways in November.