By Saryn Chorney
Is Ali Lohan turning into her big, bad sister Lindsay? According to Life & Style Weekly, the lil' Lohan spawn follows her big sis everywhere, including her closet. "Ali is 15 going on 16 and dresses her age, so there are some outfits that just work," says Dina Lohan, who is actually 46 going on 15 herself.
Personally, we're a little on the fence about the issue. Dressing like Lindsay is one thing, but actually turning into her? That's another beast entirely. So we did what any celebrity web site would do: We gathered a handful of photos and consulted our Magic 8-Ball …
Last fall, Lindsay and Ali appeared together at Henri Bendel's in New York to promote LiLo's new collection of 6126 leggings. Sporting similar black wrap tunics and matching Mona Lisa smiles, Ali definitely seems to be under the aspirational influence of her famous older sister.
Magic 8-Ball Answer: SIGNS POINT TO YES.
At the premiere of "The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants 2" in New York last summer, Ali defied Lindsay's "Leggings only!" orders and wore a pair of real pants. From their slouchy style, we assume they weren't made of that stretchy leggings-esque denim either.
Magic 8-Ball Verdict: MY SOURCES SAY NO.
OK, now this is more like it: Here's little Ali walking the runway at the Child magazine fall 2007 Fashion Week show in New York. She's wearing Tibi leggings — not Lindsay's label — but her heart, or, uh, her legs seem to be in the right place.
Magic 8-Ball Says: CANNOT PREDICT NOW.
Ali-cat sported feline ears, a bow-tie and some PG-13 cleavage under a white fishnet top (as well as black leggings, natch) to Animal Fair Magazine's 8th annual Halloween pet costume party last fall. Does this mean she's turning into a party animal like Lindsay? Meh, seems more like Paris Hilton territory to us.
Magic 8-Ball Response: REPLY HAZY, TRY AGAIN.
Ever since Lindsay started dating Samantha Ronson, Dina Lohan has been feeling empty nest syndrome. No wonder she's turned to Ali as her new underage, of-the-womb partner in questionable parenting skills crime.
Magic 8-Ball Reply: IT IS DECIDEDLY SO.
Holy Lohan! In this photo, Ali is truly the spitting image of Lindsay, with her long, dark locks, collagen-enhanced pout and a bewildered stare.
Wait — what? That's a Lindsay pic from '06, you say? Oops. Our bad.
Magic 8-Ball Final Verdict: OUTLOOK NOT SO GOOD.