Awkward! Fans may be clamoring for a Saved by the Bell reunion, but if Tiffani Thiessen's reaction to a surprise visit from her former TV principal, Dennis Haskins, is any indication, Kelly Kapowski will not be part of it. At least, not by choice.

PHOTOS: Saved by the Bell stars: Where are they now?

Thiessen, 39, who currently stars on USA's White Collar, was not feeling the love when Haskins, 62, stopped by the TODAY show during her Feb. 5 guest appearance. She played along when the set was transformed to resemble Bayside hangout The Max, and when anchor Natalie Morales challenged her to a '90s trivia game -- but she couldn't hide her discomfort when Principal Belding walked in quoting his famous catchphrase: "Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey! What is going on here?"

"Can I just say hi real quick?" Haskins asked Al Roker as he extended a friendly hand toward Thiessen, who barely managed a half-hearted smile for her former costar. Sensing the awkwardness between the two, Morales piped in: "Tiffani's in shock!"

PHOTOS: '90s TV stars, then and now

Perhaps not surprisingly, Thiessen was the main holdout when Jimmy Fallon tried to get the Bayside gang back together on his late-night show in 2009. She even filmed a Funny or Die video in which she listed all of the reasons she couldn't make it. Among the (mostly fictional) activities on her "to do" list ahead of reuniting with her former cast mates? Working with NASA on a new fuel cell for the next space shuttle, singing in an Indigo Girls tribute band, training for the UFC tai chi competition, and looking hot while sitting by her pool.

PHOTOS: Celebrity yearbook pictures

Haskins, on the other hand, is more than eager to stage a meet-up with his ex students. "I've kind of carried the banner for Saved by the Bell for a bunch of years, because -- let's face it -- I'll be Mr. Belding for the rest of my life," Haskins told, adding that he has stayed in touch with Mario Lopez and Mark-Paul Gosselaar, who played A.C. Slater and Zack Morris, respectively. (Incidentally, Lopez and Haskins ran into each other at a 1990s-themed bash in West Hollywood on Jan. 31.)

"I have always supported a reunion of any kind including all of us," he told TMZ recently. "Honestly, the fans still love us and our show so much...They deserve it!"

This article originally appeared on Tiffani Thiessen Awkwardly Reunites With Dennis Haskins, Saved by the Bell's Mr. Belding