There's something fishy when both parties in a rumored romance go on TV and dispute those reports. In 2009, when Ellen DeGeneres asked Nicollette if she was dating David, she replied, "We're just friends, we're not dating. . . . Do you see us together? No!" And when Ellen showed David (and the audience!) this segment, he laughed and responded, "I think it's less dating and more her killing time." Well played, player. Well played.