Two big stars, two big events, one big problem.

PHOTOS: Stars' 2011 American Music Awards style

The Band Perry's lead singer Kimberly Perry turned heads in Bottega Veneta on the red carpet at Sunday's American Music Awards. The only issue? Emma Stone wore the same exact dress five month earlier at the MTV Movie Awards.

PHOTOS: Vote for which stars wore it best!

The 28-year-old country singer even carried the same Bottega Veneta clutch that Stone brought with her to the MTV event. Fortunately, Perry chose different footwear than The Help star: The AMA nominee and performer chose a pair of strappy gold and black sandals, while Stone, 23, wore orange satin Casadei pumps.

Tell Us: Which star wore Bottega Veneta better?

Get more Us! Follow us on Twitter, Friend us on Facebook, Subscribe to Us Weekly