By Charles Switzer
11:30am PDT, Apr 15, 2025
Trump Defies Supreme Court Order on Abrego Garcia's Return
President
Donald Trump and his administration have refused to comply with a Supreme Court order that mandates the return of
Kilmar Abrego Garcia, an immigrant wrongly sent to a Salvadoran prison,
HuffPost reported.
In an order issued on Friday, April 11, the Supreme Court unanimously declared that the Trump administration must "facilitate" Garcia's release from custody in El Salvador and ensure his case is handled as if he had not been improperly sent to the country.
Here's what's happening.
MORE:
Follow Wonderwall on MSN for more top news
The Trump Administration's Defiance of the Court's Ruling
Despite the clear directive from the Supreme Court, the Donald Trump administration has attempted to spin the decision as a victory for them, falsely claiming that the court ruled "in our favor."
During a meeting with Salvadoran President
Nayib Bukele, Trump asserted that the court had decided in his administration's favor.
Attorney General
Pam Bondi further misrepresented the ruling, stating that the only requirement was for the administration to "provide a plane" if Bukele chose to release Kilmar Abrego Garcia, even though this was not the case according to the Supreme Court's decision.
Abrego Garcia's Detention and the Legal Dispute
Kilmar Abrego Garcia was
wrongfully removed to El Salvador in March 2023, along with other immigrants, despite the fact that an immigration judge found his testimony credible and granted him withholding removal status.
The judge had ruled that Garcia was not a member of the MS-13 gang, a claim made against him in 2019 that was never substantiated.
The administration ignored this ruling and sent him to the Salvadoran prison CECOT, despite the legal status that prevented his deportation. Lawyers for the Department of Justice admitted in court that Abrego Garcia's removal was a mistake, yet they have continued to deny any responsibility to bring him back.
The Administration's False Statements and New Allegations
Since the Supreme Court ruling, Donald Trump's second administration has refused to provide basic information regarding Kilmar Abrego Garcia's location and what steps are being taken to comply with the court's order.
On Saturday, April 12, the administration reported that Garcia was still in CECOT but failed to answer questions about his status and the administration's actions.
In a new claim, the administration argued that Garcia was no longer eligible for withholding removal because of his alleged gang affiliation, even though this accusation was previously disproven by the courts. This new assertion contradicts the findings of the original trial and is a clear attempt to evade compliance with the court's order.
Implications of Defying the Court's Ruling
The Donald Trump administration's refusal to comply with the Supreme Court's order highlights the broader issue of executive overreach and defiance of the judiciary.
By redefining the meaning of "facilitate" in a way that avoids the court's original intent, the administration is pushing the
boundaries of executive power. The court's ruling explicitly ordered the administration to "facilitate" Kilmar Abrego Garcia's return to the U.S. and ensure due process.
However, the administration has instead chosen to reinterpret this as merely removing obstacles to his return, a stance that undermines the rule of law.
If this defiance is allowed to stand, it could set a dangerous precedent for future cases. The administration's actions suggest that any U.S. citizen or immigrant can be detained and sent to a foreign country without due process, based solely on unsubstantiated accusations.
