Before she danced her way to happiness with "Black Swan" dancer Benjamin Millepied and gave birth to little Aleph, she dug the long-haired, short jean shorts wearing, singer-songwriter Barnhart. We knew she had a weird hipster side to her, but this seemed like a little much for an Aleph-list movie star, which is probably why it only lasted a short time in 2008. A year later, he told New York magazine, "She's one of my best friends. I love her super much. Super much."