Ever since starting his career as a Yankee, Derek Jeter has been New York's most eligible bachelor. Despite a slew of famous girlfriends -- and believe us, there are so many more -- Jeter hasn't settled down yet. He dated Mariah in 1996, when she was at the top of her career and her hits wouldn't stop coming. Then 10 years later, Jeter hooked up with Jessica Biel just as she was shedding her good girl image from "7th Heaven." Most recently, it seemed like Minka Kelly was going to make an honest man out of this shortstop, but they have gone their separate ways.