In July 2005, a dirty little secret from Colin's past reared its ugly little head. (No pun intended.) A sex tape starring the actor and former Playboy Playmate Nicole Narain was released on the Web. Though fingers pointed at his former flame as the one who leaked the video and Colin sued her to prevent the sale of the video, she denied any wrongdoing. The pair eventually reached a settlement in 2006. In the end, did Colin think that the sexy home video was worth it? "An expensive 14 minutes, that one ... It seemed like a good idea at the time," the actor later revealed.