The "Lost" star was arrested for DUI in Oregon on May 4, but even more embarrassing than the fact that this was his second alcohol-related arrest in less than a year are the details of his first offense. The actor was arrested in Ohio on Aug. 28, 2011, for allegedly punching a female bus driver repeatedly after she refused to let him board a private party bus. "He smelled like a liquor cabinet, like a bar," the driver later said. Matthew was never officially charged with assaulting the driver, and in fact, he counter-sued. But regardless of the end result, there's no denying the incident made for some pretty embarrassing headlines.