- Photo: Gary Gershoff/WireImage.com3 of 10
From Zachary's dating past, we know he has a thing for blondes. So this fair-haired Carey would surely pique his interest. Sure, they're pretty much opposites, but we could totally picture her loving his goofy ways and him being enamored with her British accent. Besides, Carey could use a change of pace after dating Shia LaBeouf.