We're making a list and checking it twice. In honor of Santa's List Day, we're helping Ol' Saint Nick figure out which celebs have been naughty this year and which have been nice. Here's the drill: We'll make a case for each in question, and you get to vote whether they deserve presents or coal this Christmas. Ho, ho, ho -- let's go!
Case for naughty: From smoking pot onstage to singing about MDMA, Miley made one thing abundantly clear this year: The girl likes to use drugs. Miley also spent her year twerking in barely-there ensembles. Plus, something must be said for the fact that she subjected us to that stupid tongue of hers all year long.
Case for nice: She just went through a major breakup. Maybe we should cut her some slack.