According to "Here I Go Again" video vixen Tawny Kitaen, a pre-fame Kristin Cavallari once shoplifted merchandise from her Tawny K. boutique in Orange County, Calif. Tawny claims K.Cav was one of four girls from Laguna Beach who were arrested after the model caught them stuffing their bags during a visit to her store. Years later, Tawny and her daughter spotted an advertisement for "Laguna Beach" and recognized Kristin as one of the thieves. "My daughter is like, 'Oh my God. She was the one who stole from your store.' And now she's this big thing," Tawny told Blender magazine.