In February 2011, the troubled starlet was accused of stealing a $2,500 necklace from a jewelry store in Venice, Calif. Lindsay maintained she simply forgot she was wearing the necklace when she left the boutique, and 10 days after the one-of-a-kind bling went missing -- and after investigators were issued a warrant to search her home -- the starlet finally returned the necklace. She was charged with a misdemeanor, and found to be in violation of her probation stemming from a DUI conviction.
It wasn't the first time the "Mean Girls" star was accused of stealing: In 2008, Lindsay allegedly stole a $11,000 mink coat from a fellow party goer at a New York nightclub. That same year, a model alleged Lindsay stole thousands of dollars of clothes from her closet during a party. In 2009, Lindsay was suspected of taking $400,000 in Dior jewelry from a London photo shoot. And in 2010, the actress was questioned about a $35,000 Rolex watch that went missing after a "friend" left it in her home.