- Photo: Laurent Despois/Splash News1 of 10
By Dana Flax
Since the announcement of Simon Cowell's upcoming retirement from "American Idol" last week, we couldn't help but wonder who could possibly take over such important duties as pop music purist (and official side-eye-giver) for the show's 10th season. Click through to see which judicious folks we'd nominate to the supreme court of "American Idol."
From Crowd Ignite